Federal Judge Strikes Down DHS Rule Limiting Visa Stays for International Medical Residents
A federal court struck down a U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) rule that would have limited how long international medical residents and fellows could remain in the U.S. for training. Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts entered a final judgment on November 16 that threw out the rule.
What the Rule Would Have Changed
Under the long-standing “duration of status” system, F, J, and I visa holders may remain in the country for the length of their program. The DHS rule would have replaced that system with fixed admission periods:
- Students and exchange visitors: Four years
- Foreign journalists: 240 days
Because many training programs last longer than four years, residents would have had to request an extension partway through training. Approval would have been at DHS’ discretion, with no right of appeal. The process would have introduced additional burdens for trainees in extended programs, including general surgery residencies, which last five years, and neurosurgery residencies, which last seven.
The American Hospital Association estimates that the rule would have affected nearly 17,000 physicians in residency and fellowship programs nationwide.
Why the Court Threw Out the Rule
According to Becker's Healthcare, Saylor granted summary judgment to a coalition of higher education groups and labor unions that challenged the rule. He found it arbitrary and contrary to law under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court found that DHS:
- Did not weigh the rule’s costs and benefits
- Did not provide adequate support for its rationale that the rule would prevent fraud and protect national security
- Did not consider less burdensome alternatives, including strengthening the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, which already requires schools and program sponsors to report on visa holders
- Exceeded its statutory authority by imposing limits on academic programs
DHS’ Request and What Comes Next
DHS asked the court to return the rule to the agency for further review while leaving it in place. Saylor declined, noting that the current system has been in place for decades and that the rule never took effect.
DHS’ appeal of the September injunction is still pending before the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Learn More
- U.S. District Court Ruling
- American Hospital Association Coverage
- Becker’s Hospital Review: September Injunction
Information sourced from Becker's Healthcare.






